Verified Document

The Influence Of Language Essay

Sapir Whorf hypothesis is an extremely important theory (or at least basis for theoretical discussion) within the field of linguistics. Moreover, it has implications for the very definition of reality as it is perceived by people. One of the key tenets of this hypothesis is the relationship between culture, language and thought. The hypothesis poses the notion that language influences thought. The degree that it influences thought is up to debate. There are some adherents who believe that language determines thought and that "meaning is locked within the grammatical and semantic structure of individual languages" (Collin, 2013, p. 282). Others believe that language merely "influences" (Wenzel, 2011, p. 458) thought. What is less mutable is the concept that culture helps to determine language, and in this way ultimately helps to influence thought. The fundamental notion of this hypothesis is that the words one uses -- which are specific to various languages -- greatly impact what one thinks about, as well as how one thinks about it. This tenet is predicated on the viewpoint that people think in terms of words, or in terms of language. To this end, there are various points of stratification about "reality" (Carnes, 1970, p. 263) to which language ultimately confines a thinker....

People do not necessarily think outside of those terms, because they have no terms to categorize or to figuratively 'voice' their thoughts.
It would be difficult to outright refute the Sapir Whorf hypothesis. Most people think in terms of language. Therefore, it is plausible that the very terms and intricacies of language itself impact the way one thinks, what one thinks about, etc. Moreover, there are various forms of research that appear aligned with this hypothesis, or which perhaps even outright support it. Collin (2013) wrote an article underlying the difficulty of translating important political terms and their underlying ideas. In doing so, he noted that "abstract nouns like justice, soul, sovereignty, and leader are all embedded within overall signification systems and possess special associations" (Collin, 2013, p. 283). Some of the terms identified in this passage, in addition to the systems of signification and their special associations, certainly vary according to time in space. The term justice among Jews in post World War II concentration camps is much different than the same term in a plagiarism suit against a student today. These examples buttress the Sapir Whorf hypothesis.

Although the Sapir Whorf hypothesis is feasible,…

Sources used in this document:
References

Carnes. R.L. (2014). A perceptual model of the whorfian thesis. ETC. 27(1), 263-271.

Collin, R.O. (2012). Moving political meaning across linguistic frontiers. Political Studies. 61, 282-300.

Wenzel, C.H. (2011). Isolation and involvement: Wilhelm von Humboldt, Francois Jullien, and more. Philosophy East & West. 60(4), 458-475.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now